Skip to content
Sample verification

One agent action, verified against the systems of record.

The payment was refunded, but the order remained active and could still ship.

A support agent refunded an order on a customer's request. This is exactly what your team sees for every action: the contract it was checked against, each check with the fact behind it, the outcome and policy lenses with their hashes, and the raw facts. The agent's own report of success is recorded but never used as evidence.

Synthetic demo data. Vendors, counts and amounts are generated for illustration and do not describe any real customer or vendor.
refund_order · onboarding-order-001FAIL
Contract:Stripe Customer Operations: refund an order
Limit:amount above 250 — within limit (42.5)
Across actions:sum of amount across stripe.refund over 24h per subject above 250 — within limit (42.5)
Expected effects:3
  • stripe.refund observed within 1h of the action, from a source rated independent or better, from backend attested evidence or strongerobserved 02:10:47
  • shopify.order_cancelled observed within 1h of the action, from a source rated independent or better, from backend attested evidence or strongerNOT OBSERVED
  • zendesk.status_change observed within 1h of the action where to=solved, from a source rated shared or better, from backend attested evidence or strongerobserved 02:10:51
Forbidden:more than 1 stripe.refund effect(s) observed within 1h — none observed
Forbidden:stripe.refund amount differs from the action's amount (tolerance 0.01) — none observed
Forbidden:shopify.fulfillment_created observed within 1h of the action — none observed
Reversed:stripe.refund_failed observed within 30d of the action, undoing it — none observed
Reversed:shopify.order_reopened observed within 30d of the action, undoing it — none observed
Reversed:zendesk.reopen observed within 30d of the action, undoing it — none observed
Reversed:shopify.fulfillment_created observed within 30d of the action, undoing it — none observed
Result:FAIL
Reason:The order was not cancelled after the refund
Evidence hash:sha256:316522a95ee9b56f… Verify publicly

Action

Action
onboarding-sample-01m7pa8t873e6b2sz4qxc49efm
Type
Refund order
Subject
onboarding-order-001 (order)
Requested
Nov 18, 2026, 02:10 UTC
Workflow
refund_order
Agent
commitlayer-onboarding-sample-agent
Channel
—
Contract
scop_refund_order v1 · window 1h
Status
Settled
Evidence received
2 of 3 sources
Eligible evidence
0 of 3 sources
Expected effects satisfied
2 of 3
Version
Verdict version 1 · computed when the action was recorded
Evidence
Frozen at Nov 18, 2026, 03:12 UTC

Sources

Who the facts came from, and how far each source had reported when the verdict was computed. Trust determines whether evidence is eligible to satisfy a contract. Changing a source's attestation may change affected verdicts and triggers reverification.

  • shopifySample sourcewatermark Nov 18, 2026, 03:12 UTC
  • stripeSample sourcewatermark Nov 18, 2026, 03:12 UTC
  • zendeskSample sourcewatermark Nov 18, 2026, 03:12 UTC

Facts that decided checks: 3 sample source.

Parameters

{
  "amount": 42.5,
  "currency": "USD",
  "customer_id": "onboarding-customer-001"
}

Checks

Every check in the contract, with the fact that satisfied it (or did not). Facts are read from the systems of record; the agent's own report is not consulted.

Checks with per-check evidence
CheckResultSourceFact Occurred atValue
A refund may not exceed the approved amount
Limit
Refund stayed within the approved amountparams——42.5
Refunds on one order may not add up to more than the approved amount
Across actions · refund
Refunds on this order stayed within the approved amountstripeSample sourcefct_01m7pa8t8z87g023psad4grq2sNov 18, 2026, 02:10 UTC42.5
The refund must be on the order's own payment, so it reaches the intended customer
Expected effect · refund
Expected effect observedRefund matched the intended customerstripeSample sourcefct_01m7pa8t8z87g023psad4grq2sNov 18, 2026, 02:10 UTC{"amount":42.5,"currency":"usd","status":"succeeded"}
The order must be cancelled after the refund
Expected effect · order_cancelled
No evidence receivedshopify———
zendesk.status_change observed within 1h of the action where to=solved, from a source rated shared or better, from backend attested evidence or stronger
Expected effect · status_change
Expected effect observedzendeskSample sourcefct_01m7pa8t91jwkzfars1cwrnct8Nov 18, 2026, 02:10 UTC{"from":"open","to":"solved"}
Only one refund may be issued
Forbidden effect · refund
No duplicate refund detectedstripe———
The refund must be for the amount the agent recorded
Forbidden effect · refund
Refund matched the approved amountstripe———
shopify.fulfillment_created observed within 1h of the action
Forbidden effect · fulfillment_created
Not observedshopify———
stripe.refund_failed observed within 30d of the action, undoing it
Reversal · refund_failed
Not reversedstripe———
shopify.order_reopened observed within 30d of the action, undoing it
Reversal · order_reopened
Not reversedshopify———
zendesk.reopen observed within 30d of the action, undoing it
Reversal · reopen
Not reversedzendesk———
shopify.fulfillment_created observed within 30d of the action, undoing it
Reversal · fulfillment_created
Not reversedshopify———

Lenses

Outcome lens

Did the intended outcome land in the systems of record?

FAIL

FAIL: Verified condition not met

  • Verified condition not met verified_condition_not_met

    None of the conditions that would verify the claim were satisfied.

  • Expected effect not observed: shopify order_cancelled expected_effect_missing:shopify.order_cancelled

    The contract expects shopify order_cancelled after the action, and no matching fact was observed inside the settlement window.

Raw verdict
NOT_VERIFIED
Computed
Nov 18, 2026, 03:12 UTC
Verdict hash
aa07b6ef8a37438a…
Previous
140c2f14ff18a260…
Evidence
2 pointers

Policy lens

Was the action valid, within limits, and free of forbidden effects?

FAIL

FAIL: Verified condition not met

  • Verified condition not met verified_condition_not_met

    None of the conditions that would verify the claim were satisfied.

  • Expected effect not observed: shopify order_cancelled expected_effect_missing:shopify.order_cancelled

    The contract expects shopify order_cancelled after the action, and no matching fact was observed inside the settlement window.

Raw verdict
NOT_VERIFIED
Computed
Nov 18, 2026, 03:12 UTC
Verdict hash
316522a95ee9b56f… Verify
Previous
aa07b6ef8a37438a…
Evidence
2 pointers

Facts

As the engine saw them when the verdict settled, Nov 18, 2026, 03:12 UTC.

  1. Order statusNov 18, 2026, 02:10 UTCshopifySample source
    Sample source — generated by CommitLayer for this guided run. This source is pre-verified only for the onboarding sample. It cannot satisfy a real production action. CommitLayer generated it for one onboarding sample run, after checking that run's token.
    status: open · total: 42.5 · currency: USD
    fct_01m7pa8t8ppkhhwkjsna6j61rs · onboarding_sample:smp_01m7pa8t873e6b2sz4qxc49efm:0
  2. RefundNov 18, 2026, 02:10 UTCstripeSample source
    Sample source — generated by CommitLayer for this guided run. This source is pre-verified only for the onboarding sample. It cannot satisfy a real production action. CommitLayer generated it for one onboarding sample run, after checking that run's token.
    amount: 42.5 · currency: usd · status: succeeded
    fct_01m7pa8t8z87g023psad4grq2s · onboarding_sample:smp_01m7pa8t873e6b2sz4qxc49efm:1
  3. Status changeNov 18, 2026, 02:10 UTCzendeskSample source
    Sample source — generated by CommitLayer for this guided run. This source is pre-verified only for the onboarding sample. It cannot satisfy a real production action. CommitLayer generated it for one onboarding sample run, after checking that run's token.
    from: open · to: solved
    fct_01m7pa8t91jwkzfars1cwrnct8 · onboarding_sample:smp_01m7pa8t873e6b2sz4qxc49efm:2

Pick the failure yourself in the Failure Lab